The Internet Newspaper: News, Blogs, Video, Community Edition: U.S. CA Canada Québec FR France ES Spain US United States UK United Kingdom FRONT PAGEPolitics Mitt Romney Makes Birth Certificate Joke43kWhy Do Fox News Female Anchors Wear So Much Makeup?4kAnn Romney's Heartbreaking Loss8kThe Most Iconic White House Photos Of Obama's First Term145Romney's Tax Strategy May Have Employed Legally Dubious Maneuvers: Experts13k Go to Politics More in PoliticsPollster2012 BlogSpeculatronOff The BusElection DashboardYou might also likeWorldGreenBlack VoicesLatino VoicesGay VoicesBusiness 10 Things You Should Never Pay For282Target Hides Horrible Truth From Customers2kRomney Will Be President, CU Professors' Model Predicts27kAmerica's Most Frequently Stolen Cars69Leaked Documents Link Romney Money To Some Shady Business25k Go to Business More in BusinessSmall BusinessMoneyYou might also likeWorldTechMediaArtsSportsWeird NewsCrimeEntertainment Hollywood Heavyweight: Obama Is A Dud1kOprah Was Called The N-Word After Ellen's Coming Out Episode1kEXCLUSIVE: Jerry Seinfeld Opens Up About New Web Series106WATCH: Rachel McAdams & Noomi Rapace Get Their Black Swan On134'Black Swan' Intern Lawsuit Wins Skirmish52 Go to Entertainment More in EntertainmentCelebrityTVYou might also likeComedyArtsBooksFoodStyleWeird NewsMoviefoneTV Lisa Rinna Reveals Potential New Gig50Hoda & Kathie Lee Learn Drinking Early Isn't Healthy83The Ultimate Fall TV Guide To Your Favorite ShowsOprah Was Called The N-Word After Ellen's Coming Out Episode1kLOOK: Who's Missing From The 'Glee' Season 4 Promo Photos?11 Go to TV More in TVTV ReplayTV RecapsTV SpoilersMaureen RyanMaggie FurlongYou might also likeCelebrityMediaComedyArtsBooksWeird News TAKING A GAMBLE: This Mountain Lion Invaded A Reno Casino138Stick-Wielding Bigfoot Runs Across Ohio Path In Front Of Startled Biker1kWhat A Whopper! Hawaii Woman Reels Half-ton Marlin215Late Night Naked Dance Party Of One Wakes Woman45Mummified Diver Found 13 Years After He Saved A Life183 Go to Weird News More in Weird NewsDumb CrimeUFOWorld RecordsAnatomical WondersZombie ApocalypseOctomomYou might also likeComedyTechScienceCrimeSports Armstrong Ends Fight, Faces HUGE Loss3kWATCH: Ryan Lochte's Sister Is Racist, Not Funny777USADA To Strip Lance Armstrong Of 7 Tour Titles2kUFC Makes (Unwanted) History444Lance Armstrong Won't Fight Drug Charges4k Go to Sports More in SportsLondon 2012Olympics Event ScheduleMedal MapYou might also likeTVFoodTechComedyWeird NewsCrimeTech Apple vs. Samsung: The Verdict Is In3kRich Kids Of Instagram, Norwegian Royals Edition?141Netflix Adds Intriguing New Indie Films475What You Need To Know About The Apple-Samsung Verdict1k5 Things Tim Cook Is Doing Better Than Steve Jobs88 Go to Tech More in TechBest of TEDSocial MediaYou might also likeSmall BusinessGreenScienceNew YorkSan FranciscoTechCrunchEngadgetJoystiqScience WATCH: New Hi-Def Video Shows Mars Rover's Dizzying Descent450NASA Makes Mars Tribute To Bradbury46Can A Baby Cry In French?46Why Is Thinking So Hard?623Glitch Forces NASA To Reschedule Launch Of 'Radiation' Probes11 Go to Science More in ScienceSpaceBrainEarthTalk Nerdy To MeWeird ScienceYou might also likeTechGreenArtsReligionWeird NewsWorld 100-Year-Old Mystery Package Opened1k100-Year-Old Package With Message Not To Open Until 2012 Set To Be Unveiled 1kRich Kids Of Instagram, Norwegian Royals Edition?141Armstrong Ends Fight, Faces HUGE Loss3kU.S. Government Employees Reportedly Shot In Mexico2k Go to World More in WorldForeign AffairsDrug WarAfghanistan WarSyriaWorld VideosYou might also likeTravelPoliticsBusinessTechReligionLIVEALL SECTIONS NewsPoliticsWorldBusinessSmall BusinessMoneyMediaSportsEducationCrimeWeird NewsGood NewsEntertainmentEntertainmentCelebrityComedyArts & CultureBooksTVMoviefoneLife & StyleHealthy LivingGPS for the SoulStyleFoodKitchen DailyWeddingsTravelParentsDivorceHuff/Post 50StylelistStylelist HomeTech & ScienceTechScienceGreenTechCrunchEngadgetTUAWJoystiqVoicesWomenBlack VoicesLatino VoicesVoces (en español)Gay VoicesReligionCollegeTeenImpactLocalChicagoDCDenverDetroitMiamiNew YorkLos AngelesSan FranciscoPatch.comMapquestAOL Daily FinanceAol JobsAol AutosAutoblogAol MusicOn.AolGames.comHeidi KlumAol ShoppingReal EstateCrimeJames HolmesTrayvon MartinLuka MagnottaJoran van der SlootBath SaltsMissing PeopleMug ShotsDeath PenaltyBizarre WeaponsQuizzes
Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributorsHot on the BlogJeff JarvisRobert ReichMarian Wright EdelmanBill Maher HuffPost Social Reading
Some error occurred Login with Facebook to see what your friends are reading Enable Social Reading i
Settings Read Share Settings Share everything I read Share only things safe for work Dont share what I'm reading Read Share History Learn More Tom KrattenmakerAuthor, 'Onward Christian Athletes' GET UPDATES FROM Tom Krattenmaker Like 20 Has Tony Perkins Seen The Light On Hate Speech?Posted: 08/24/2012 4:30 pm React
Inspiring
Funny
Scary
Hot
Crazy
Important
Weird
Follow
#news_entries #ad_sharebox_260x60 img {padding:0px;margin:0px} share this story Submit this storydiggredditstumble
Published originally on USAToday.com, Aug. 24.
Thank you, Family Research Council, for now conceding what conservative groups have been loath to acknowledge in recent years: the truth that incendiary rhetoric indeed does contribute to a climate conducive to politically motivated violence.
Never has the moment seemed more opportune to forge consensus around an overdue new rule in the culture wars. Starting now, can we all please watch our words?
Most likely, you're aware of the incident that ignited this renewed debate about rhetoric and violence. Last week, a volunteer from a Washington, D.C., community center for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people walked into the headquarters of the Family Research Council, an influential conservative Christian organization, with a gun, a box of ammunition and a burning grudge against the group and its anti-gay politics and rhetoric, authorities said. The suspect, according to court documents, shot a security guard in the arm before he was subdued by that same guard and taken into custody.
Thank goodness no one was killed and that the security guard acted so heroically to prevent the incident from getting far worse. The group's fiercest opponents in the ongoing national arguments -- organizations representing ardent secularists and gay-rights advocates -- were quick to condemn the shooting, and rightly so. Conservatives have likewise been clear, for the most part, in their denunciations of violence committed against liberal figures over the years.
Here's where the plot gets thicker.
Since the shooting, Family Research Council President Tony Perkins has been implicating the "reckless rhetoric" that gay-rights groups have been leveling against his organization in recent years, especially the charge that FRC is a hate group. The Southern Poverty Law Center, a widely respected civil rights group, made waves in 2010 when it issued a new list of gay-rights opponents that the center deemed "hate groups"-- a list that includes FRC.
Perkins contends that the man charged in the shooting, Floyd Lee Corkins, "was given a license by ... the Southern Poverty Law Center who ... labeled us a hate group because we defend the family and we stand for traditional orthodox Christianity."
Perkins' charge is irritating for misstating the reason for FRC's inclusion on the hate-group list. As the Southern Poverty Law Center stressed when it released the list and in the days after last week's shooting, spreading false propaganda about LGBT people is the reason for the hate-group label, not FRC's stand against gay marriage or its defense of traditionalist views on families and faith. If you doubt the truth of that, consider the fact that the SPLC has notably left Focus on the Family off its hate group list and credited the Colorado-based evangelical organization for moderating its tone even while continuing its strong stand for traditional marriage and Christianity.
Yet there's something promising about Perkins' statement: his overdue acknowledgment, unintended though it might be, of the role of rhetoric in political violence. This is something many conservative groups like his have disclaimed in the aftermath of shootings against liberal targets in recent years, from abortion provider George Tiller (fatal) to ex-congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords (not fatal but career-ending).
In a revealing episode in 2009, when many liberals were implicating right-wing rhetoric in Tiller's murder, Perkins rejected any relationship between language and violence. The FRC chief rushed to the defense of Fox News television hostBill O'Reilly, who was being widely accused of stoking the shooter's rage by referring to Tiller as "Tiller the Baby Killer" and likening late-term abortions to the sinister practices of the Nazis.
O'Reilly, Perkins said at the time, was an "easy target for the liberal media who tried to pin some of the blame on O'Reilly, saying he incited the violence by decrying these unnecessary procedures on his show. "Despite the unfair allegations, O'Reilly spoke the truth, bringing new light to a gruesome procedure. On behalf of ... millions of values voters, we want to express our gratitude to a culture warrior who uses his national platform to promote life."
Given his statements since the FRC shooting, we can only assume that Perkins has now seen the light.
Is it fair and responsible to label FRC a hate group? Whichever side of the debate you take, realize the distinction the SPLC is making between the organizations on its anti-gay hate-groups list -- groups shown to repeatedly scapegoat and slander homosexuals with malicious misinformation -- and groups like Focus on the Family that have gotten out of the demonization game, and are nowhere to be found on the hate list.
Not all FRC critics, alas, are equally careful. Some gay-advocacy groups and secular-progressive culture warriors have been fast and loose with that "hate" label, indiscriminately attaching it to any traditionalist who has the temerity to voice the opinion that gay marriage is a bad idea. I disagree with that position, but I reject the notion that holding to it automatically constitutes hate.
Enough with pinning "hate group" on all conservative Christian organizations. Enough with likening abortion-providers to Nazis and death merchants. Enough with campaign rhetoric such as Vice President Biden's warning to an audience with a large black presence that the Republicans are bent on putting "y'all back in chains." This "reckless rhetoric," to use Perkins' term, is not the cause of violence, but it certainly throws fuel on the fire.
Both sides in the culture war now have blood on their hands, and blood on their doorsteps. Take it from Tony Perkins and the Family Research Council -- hostile rhetoric does bear a share of the blame.
It's time to check ourselves and start taking better care of the words we use for our political opponents.
Tom Krattenmaker is a Portland-based writer specializing in religion in public life and member of USA TODAY's Board of Contributors. He is the author of the forthcoming book The Evangelicals You Don't Know.
This Blogger's Books from
Onward Christian Athletes: Turning Ballparks into Pulpits and Players into Preachersby Tom Krattenmaker FOLLOW CRIME Like 37k Get Alerts #ad_bottom_article_text {margin-bottom: 15px} Religion and PoliticsPublished originally on USAToday.com, Aug. 24.Thank you, Family Research Council, for now conceding what conservative groups have been loath to acknowledg...Published originally on USAToday.com, Aug. 24.Thank you, Family Research Council, for now conceding what conservative groups have been loath to acknowledg... Related News On Huffington Post:
Mitt Romney's Culture War Distraction: How A Job-Centric Campaign Got Sidetracked Tony Perkins, Family Research Council President, Pins Shooting Blame On 'Reckless' Southern Poverty Law Center William G. 'Jerry' Boykin, Former Army Officer, Hired By Family Research Council Tony Perkins On Gay Pride Month: 'Adultery' And 'Drunkenness' Prides Are Comparable Tony Perkins, Christian Opponent Of Same Sex Marriage, Agrees To Dinner With Gay Family
Mitt Romney's Culture War Distraction: How A Job-Centric Campaign Got Sidetracked
Tony Perkins, Family Research Council President, Pins Shooting Blame On 'Reckless' Southern Poverty Law Center
William G. 'Jerry' Boykin, Former Army Officer, Hired By Family Research Council
Tony Perkins On Gay Pride Month: 'Adultery' And 'Drunkenness' Prides Are Comparable
Tony Perkins, Christian Opponent Of Same Sex Marriage, Agrees To Dinner With Gay Family
Zinnia Jones: Is This Really Just 'Mainstream Christian Advocacy'?
Rev. Joanna Harader: On Abortion, Rape and Speaking for God I am appalled that those expressing the most disrespectful attitudes toward women tend to do so in the name of God. Well, I have some biblical news for the politicians out there: The people who get to speak for God are called prophets.
Wayne Self: Dana Milbank, You're Wrong on the Family Research Council Please stop asking us to sanitize the FRC's history of harmful language against us or its real human cost. What is "mainstream" about wanting to "criminalize" your fellow Americans? What is "Christian" about using falsified science to bear false witness against one's neighbor?
Wayne Besen: The Family Research Council's Dangerous Direct Mail The FRC is a legitimate hate group with a nasty habit of lying to demonize its foes. It is laughable to watch Perkins now try to play the role of moderate Christian. The shrill nature of his rhetoric appears designed to make his followers paranoid and believe their freedom is in jeopardy.
Aaron Taylor: In Defense of the Southern Poverty Law Center To my friends in the evangelical community, what happened at the headquarters of the Family Research Council was a despicable act of violence, but please don't use what happened as a pretext to exact vengeance against groups like the SPLC.
More in Crime...
Stockton Bankruptcy May Force 'Mass Exodus' Of...
Comments18Pending Comments20 View FAQ
Previewing Your Comment. This comment has not yet been posted You have exceeded your word limit by words. Please click the "Edit" button and shorten your comment.Post Comment Edit Cancel
You can post to us this information Contact us
Click here to leave a comment.HuffPost High School welcomes a lively, thoughtful debate in the comment section. Keep in mind that the articles here are penned by young authors, so please keep criticism respectful, and help us to keep this a safe and supportive place for writers of all ages to contribute.Post CommentPreview Comment To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to. Post Comment Preview Comment To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to. Share your Comment:
Post to Facebook. Post to Blogger. Post to Twitter. Post to WordPress. Post to TypePad. Post to Tumblr. Post to Yahoo! Blogger login: Blogger password: Select blog: refresh list Remember me: Wordpress host: Wordpress login: Wordpress password: Remember me: TypePad host: TypePad login: TypePad password: Select blog: refresh list Remember me: Tumblr login: Tumblr password: Remember me: Community Notice: We've made some changes to our badge program, including the additionof our newest badge: Community Curator.
View AllFavorites Recency | Popularity This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
humpfree263 Fans 36 minutes ago (11:32 AM)"Reckless rhetoric" from the left, right and center is called free speech. The price of this freedom is that sometimes those you disagree with may say offensive things. It's a great deal when you consider the alternative- "hate speech" laws enforced subjectively by the powers that be. No thanks.humpfree: "Reckless rhetoric" from the left, right and center is calledhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/humpfree/rhetoric-and-violence-in-the-culture-wars_b_1828234_180492252.htmlHistory |Permalink |Share itThis comment has been down-ranked into oblivion. View comment You have not right to carry out this operation or Error this operation.
HUFFPOST SUPER USERChristopher Stahnke41 Fans 5 hours ago ( 7:31 AM)Amen. This false equivalency has been well documented and just won't fly. When groups who believe that their positions cannot be argued about and are based on "faith" such that no matter what any of us say we are automatically wrong unless it is based on scripture are always going to end up being more abusive than liberals who are, at least theoretically, open to argument. If you show me evidence that I'm wrong I'll admit it often very reluctantly. But a fundamentalist will not consider any evidence at all that contradicts his firmly held belief. No equivalency whatsoever between the two groups.Christopher_Stahnke: Amen. This false equivalency has been well documented and justhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Christopher_Stahnke/rhetoric-and-violence-in-the-culture-wars_b_1828234_180450140.htmlHistory |Permalink |Share itThis comment has been down-ranked into oblivion. View comment You have not right to carry out this operation or Error this operation.
HUFFPOST SUPER USERTheApostateblasphemy for a half century94 Fans 6 hours ago ( 6:03 AM)Tony Perkins,aka,"the right hand of god" has one true interest....cashing the checks!TheApostate: Tony Perkins,aka,"the right hand of god" has one true interest....cashinghttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/TheApostate/rhetoric-and-violence-in-the-culture-wars_b_1828234_180443915.htmlHistory |Permalink |Share it gfe279 Fans 2 hours ago (10:02 AM)no different than the LBGT groups.......gfe: no different than the LBGT groups.......http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/gfe/rhetoric-and-violence-in-the-culture-wars_b_1828234_180471771.htmlHistory |Permalink |Share itThis comment has been down-ranked into oblivion. View comment You have not right to carry out this operation or Error this operation. Regretfully, Mr. Perkins, you either have conveniently forgotten those lessons or have chosen to ignore them.
What you and your organization do preach is intolerance when Jesus taught tolerance; divisiveness when Jesus taught us to come together; exclusion when Jesus taught us to open our hearts; hatred when Jesus taught us to love.
Mr. Perkins, you and your ilk have taken the Gospels and re-wrote them to fit your misogynistic, homophobic, intolerant doxology. And last I checked, Dante reserved a very specific circle for the hypocrites and traitors to the name of God.jgdesr1: Mr. Perkins, there is nothing 'traditional' or 'orthodox' about thehttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/jgdesr1/rhetoric-and-violence-in-the-culture-wars_b_1828234_180406373.htmlHistory |Permalink |Share itThis comment has been down-ranked into oblivion. View comment You have not right to carry out this operation or Error this operation.
Oh, wait......talkstocoyotes: "One hen, one rooster -- for life." Oh, wait......http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/talkstocoyotes/rhetoric-and-violence-in-the-culture-wars_b_1828234_180448265.htmlHistory |Permalink |Share itThis comment has been down-ranked into oblivion. View comment You have not right to carry out this operation or Error this operation.
It lends to your dubious credibility if you could manage to even post about the article in question.Tribalenvy: If you had read the article, you'd know you're obviouslyhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Tribalenvy/rhetoric-and-violence-in-the-culture-wars_b_1828234_180491929.htmlHistory |Permalink |Share itThis comment has been down-ranked into oblivion. View comment You have not right to carry out this operation or Error this operation.
JazzGuitar72343 Fans 14 hours ago (10:34 PM)It surely hasn't required that one be a social phychologist, or rocket scientist, to see the unintended and violent rconsequences of misinformation from the media and well funded "family" oriented groups in America. Cooler heads must prevail, are you listening WBC, and the hate rheteoric and mongering must stop. This is one of the best articles for common sense and truth in reporting I have read. All, the religious and non-religious alike, those who advocate peace and those for war against differences, and the fence sitters must take heed of those words.
Mr. Krattenmaker, your article is beautifully worded and sensibly patterned for human understanding. I hope your posting of this article in USATODAY got the positive responses it so richly deserves.JazzGuitar72: It surely hasn't required that one be a social phychologist,http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/JazzGuitar72/rhetoric-and-violence-in-the-culture-wars_b_1828234_180395390.htmlHistory |Permalink |Share itThis comment has been down-ranked into oblivion. View comment You have not right to carry out this operation or Error this operation.
No, I won't self-censor myself because you don't like what I have to say. Politically active free-market fundamentalists, i.e. Republicans, are using the same Big-Lie tactics pioneered by Nazi information-minister Goebbels. Is that imagery too "violent" for you? Too bad, because it's the truth.
There is nothing "promising" about Perkin's words. He fights for his cause any way he can. He thinks he can make progress by silencing his critics. No, you cannot stop speech; you cannot silence it nor would you want to any more than you would want to squelch someone's feelings. If people have those feelings, they should be communicated and investigated, not swept under the rug.
Censorship _radicalizes_ speech. If, being from USA Today, you want a safe and comfortable world, then you have to do the hard work of ameliorating the crux of the problems, not play whack-a-mole on their outcomes forever. Gain the wisdom of Jesus. Love your enemies even as they are without the need to change them first. His words ring out clearly from the Bible, even today.qwerpa: "Starting now, can we all please watch our words?" No,http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/qwerpa/rhetoric-and-violence-in-the-culture-wars_b_1828234_180379566.htmlHistory |Permalink |Share itThis comment has been down-ranked into oblivion. View comment You have not right to carry out this operation or Error this operation.
Connect with your friends Check out stories you might like, and see what your friends are sharing!
BREAKING: Gunman Shoots 5 Outside Empire State Building Recommend 6k
100-Year-Old Mystery Package OpenedLike 1k
100-Year-Old Package With Message Not To Open Until 2012 Set To Be Unveiled Like 4k
Meet The Porn Star Who Started The Syphilis OutbreakRecommend 2k
Mitt Romney Makes Birth Certificate JokeLike 3k
GRAPHIC: Did The NYT Go Too Far With This Shooting Photo?Recommend 180
Woman Gets $20,000 Tip For Driving DirectionsLike 1k
Incredible Photorealistic Drawings Made With Ballpoint PensLike 6k
13 Shot In 30 Minutes In ChicagoRecommend 2k Don't Miss HuffPost Bloggers1 of 5
George Zimmerman No Longer On Facebook After His Attorney Shuts It Down
17-Year-Old Sexual Assault Victim Responds To Attacker's Attorney
Is Skinny-Dipping In The Sea Of Galilee Sacrilegious?Video
Tigers Angels Score: Greinke And Kendrick Help Angels Beat Tigers 2-1MLB
Venus The Chimera Cat Attains Viral Fame (VIDEO)Weird Photos and Videos
Cologne Zoo Tiger Escapes, Kills Keeper In GermanyAnimals
'The New Normal' Gets Boot From Utah Station For Gay PlotlineTelevision
The Stephen Strasburg Shutdown: A DefenseBaseball
Mitt Romney 'Disappointed' At Network Convention Coverage, Moves Ann Romney SpeechRepublican Party
Tea Party Lawmakers Torn Between Ideology, RealityAuto Bailout
Mullah Dadullah Dead: Key Pakistani Taliban Figure Reportedly Killed In AfghanistanAfghanistan more big news pages » 
Sign up by clicking here. Questions? Find out more: offthebus@huffingtonpost.com
Send us your robocalls!#ofb_widget{top: 0;}#ofb_widget.fixed {position: fixed; top: 15;}var OffTheBus = {post_join_actions_url:'/gadgets/campaigns_post_join_action.php?campaign_id=',Init :function() {jQuery('#ofb_widget').css('display','');},Report:function(){if (!HPUser.is_logged_in()){QuickLogin.pop();}else{jQuery.get(OffTheBus.post_join_actions_url + "114",function(data){huff.use('modal', function(m){ m.show({ content: data, width: 750, })});HPUtil.EvalScript(data);});}},Mail:function(){huff.use('modal', function(m){ m.show({ url:"/web-services/offthebus/signup.html", width: 585,height:525, })});},Join:function(id){//add contributor to campaignsjQuery.get(OffTheBus.post_join_actions_url + id,function(data){huff.use('connect/modal', function(connect_modal){connect_modal.init(function(){huff.use('modal', function(modal){modal.show({theme:'connect_modal',content: data,width: 750,height: 550});});});});});},};jQuery(document).ready(OffTheBus.Init);jQuery(document).ready(function () { jQuery(window).scroll(function (event) {var top = jQuery('#otb_module').offset().top - parseFloat(jQuery('#otb_module').css('marginTop')); var y = jQuery(this).scrollTop();if (y >= top) { jQuery('#ofb_widget').addClass('fixed'); } else { jQuery('#ofb_widget').removeClass('fixed'); } });}); Advertise | Make HuffPost your Home Page | RSS | Careers | FAQ User Agreement | Privacy | Comment Policy | About Us | About Our Ads | Contact Us Copyright © 2012 TheHuffingtonPost.com, Inc. | "The Huffington Post" is a registered trademark of TheHuffingtonPost.com, Inc. All rights reserved. Part of HPMG News
HuffPost Lightbox
View the original article here
This post was made using the Auto Blogging Software from WebMagnates.org This line will not appear when posts are made after activating the software to full version.
ليست هناك تعليقات:
إرسال تعليق